Wamp: Health Care Is Closer To A Privilege Than A Right
By Kleinheider Posted on March 5, 2009 at 12:31 pmYour Third District Congressman and gubernatorial candidate:
“Listen, the 45 million people that don’t have health insurance — about half of them choose not to have health insurance…,” Wamp said before issuing these warnings: “If you’re on Medicare, beware. If you’re a small businessperson, he [Obama] proposes to take away your deductions for charitable contributions, for your mortgage deduction on your home, in order to pay for health care. So, if you’re one of those people who choose not to have health insurance, maybe you will have health insurance. But if you’re one of those people that currently have health care, maybe they’re going to take a benefit from you to pay for getting it to the other people. So, this is almost class warfare, in order for him to be able to say, ‘Everyone now has health care.’”
SEE ALSO: Enclave
Comments
25 Responses to “Wamp: Health Care Is Closer To A Privilege Than A Right”
Partly Cloudy
Recent Comments
- dontcallmemikey on How Do You Like Him Now?:
- TNVolunteer73 on Cloture:
Freddie There is a GOP healthcare plan. So who ever told you that is a liar. I am not a...
- TNVolunteer73 on Cloture:
Common Sense, Dont worry they will be very useful after January 2011.. Because they will be...
- common sense on Cloture:
Our GOP Senators are as useless as our GOP House members. No positive contribution. Just a...
- TNVolunteer73 on In The Ghetto:
Freddie, The problem is it is not public education 47% of the time, it is PUBLIC BABY...
- TNVolunteer73 on How Do You Like Him Now?:
Mikey Your right.. Drunk Driving and Handgun permit holders in bars is 2...
- Andy2012 on In The Ghetto:
Didn’t he advocate for the abolition of the federal Department of Education?
- Andy2012 on Cloture:
Yep, no plan from McConnell. No vote to move forward from Corker or Lamar! No “responsible...
- dontcallmemikey on How Do You Like Him Now?:
Davy - I do not condone drunk driving. It’s definitely a killer....
- Freddie O'Connell on Cloture:
I see. So there’s no Republican healthcare plan. At least he’s (sort of)...
The Collective
KnoxViews - » Senator Alexander, Are 1.2 Million Tennesseans "Ghetto"?
Posted 34 minutes ago
WisdomIsVindicated » TN gun ruling: whose Constitutional right is at stake?
Posted 82 minutes ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Rickety Structures
Posted 107 minutes ago
terryfrank.net » What Obama REALLY thinks of “his” troops
Posted 3 hours ago
Compassion in Politics: Christian Social Entrepreneurship, Education Innovation, & Base of the Pyramid/BOP Solutions » Top 100 Tools for Learning in 2009
Posted 3 hours ago
WisdomIsVindicated » Bureaucratic boobs
Posted 3 hours ago
Sharoncobb.com » BREAKING: Democrats have 60 votes to advance health bill
Posted 4 hours ago
Camp4u » No guns in bars could mean guns in ALL bars.
Posted 4 hours ago
Camp4u » Special session in December
Posted 5 hours ago
Women's Health News » More Writing On and Coverage of the Mammography Controversy
Posted 6 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » The Butcher Keeps Me On Track
Posted 6 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » Most Obscene Global Warming Alarmist Ad Yet
Posted 6 hours ago
WisdomIsVindicated » So-called scientists
Posted 8 hours ago
KnoxViews - » We waited with baited breath, turned our lonely eyes 2 U
Posted 8 hours ago
Appalachian Abroad » Obama Should End the War
Posted 10 hours ago
Compassion in Politics: Christian Social Entrepreneurship, Education Innovation, & Base of the Pyramid/BOP Solutions » Coworking, Jelly, and Coffee Shop Mashup!!!
Posted 10 hours ago
Compassion in Politics: Christian Social Entrepreneurship, Education Innovation, & Base of the Pyramid/BOP Solutions » An Open Letter to the Washington Post Online
Posted 10 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Knox candidates off and running
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » No guns in bars. Again.
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » They Work for You,
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Restaurant Review: K Town Kebabs, or "How I went to the mall, and left happy."
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Southeastern Division of the Association of American Geographers in Knoxville, Nov 22-24
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Quote of the Day
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » County Commission District 7
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » University of Calif. OKs 32 percent tuition hike
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Cortney Piper considers bid for Burchett's State Senate seat
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Obama: slacker
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » FAA: Flight delays due to computer glitch
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Public meeting re. Gay Street 100 block project
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Speaking of convergence
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Distance learning from space
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Headline of the day
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Friday marks official start of the Knox County 2010 elections
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Brown bag lunch and book discussion today with Dr. McIntyre
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » A quick note about the trial of Khalid Sheik Mohammed
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Interesting afternoon at UT
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » While City Council is Considering EZ Bonds to Upgrade the Holiday Inn,
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » NEA/AFT oppose tax on "Cadillac" health plans
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » What to do? Breast cancer screening guidelines changing?
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Environment America: 100 new nuclear reactors not the answer to global warming
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Leonid Meteor Showers Peak Tuesday
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » TNDP: Obama is not a communist
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Palin could easily get the GOP nomination in 2012 due to winner take all primaries
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Paula Flowers ready for progressive prime time?
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » 10 Differences Between Fox News and MSNBC
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Layoffs report
Posted 11 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Karaoke pirates
Posted 11 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » The Fightin Double Zero Congressional District
Posted 12 hours ago
KnoxViews - » County Commission District 7
Posted 12 hours ago
Tennesseefree.com » Voting For Health Bill Requirement of Blackness
Posted 15 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » William Jefferson's legal bills to be paid by taxpayers
Posted 15 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Knox candidates off and running
Posted 15 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » Question of the Weekend
Posted 22 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » Question of the Weekend
Posted 22 hours ago
Sharoncobb.com » The Senate Will Take Up The Health Care Bill, Today. (Saturday)
Posted 23 hours ago
Sharoncobb.com » The Making Of The Beatles--Never Seen Before Footage
Posted 23 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Sarah Palin's Uterus...
Posted 26 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Look! BUNNIES!!!11!!!1!!!
Posted 26 hours ago
Blue Collar Republican » Vote For Kelsey!!!!!!!
Posted 30 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » It Isn't Just Guns In "Bars"
Posted 31 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » It Isn't Just Guns In "Bars"
Posted 31 hours ago
Cosmopolitan Conservative » Health Care Updates
Posted 33 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Radio Fred: Thompsonism of the Month
Posted 33 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » A Vague Woo Hoo!
Posted 33 hours ago
KnoxViews - » No guns in bars. Again.
Posted 34 hours ago
Nashville Is Talking » Tennessee law allowing guns in bars ruled unconstitutional
Posted 34 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Legal costs mount for iPayment CEO
Posted 34 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Cogent prepping for acquisitions
Posted 34 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » 'Tough Trade' Open Casting Tomorrow
Posted 34 hours ago
KnoxViews - » They Work for You,
Posted 34 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Restaurant Review: K Town Kebabs, or "How I went to the mall, and left happy."
Posted 35 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Permit Patrol: 20 November 2009
Posted 36 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Western Pennsylvania…are you really that stupid?
Posted 36 hours ago
Camp4u » " Tax the employers for the non working"
Posted 36 hours ago
Camp4u » Word from Israel
Posted 37 hours ago
Recent Posts
- Special Session Alert: Christmas At The Capitol?
- Kisber And Bredesen Won’t Reneg On The Corporate Welfare
- Give Incorrect Information Everywhere, And Never Use Your Real Name
- Ole Miss Students Shout Down The Klan
- Cloture
- In The Ghetto
- He Won’t Tax And He Won’t Cut Across The Board
- Some Of His Best Children Are Black
- Praise For Gay Media
- Not Saving Anything For The Swim Back
- Something Fishy About The Land Deal For The New Westside Police Precinct?
- Guns In Bars Sponsors Promise To Try Again
- Comptroller Says We Are Headed For Lean Years
- The Death Of Velvet Thunder
- Ned Ray To Campaign For Son In A Convertible
The Latest from NashvillePost.com
- Legal costs mount for iPayment CEO
- Cogent prepping for acquisitions
- Permit Patrol: 20 November 2009
- Spheris ends SEC registration
- Law firm renews Fifth Third Center lease
- Tin Roof owners sue lawyer for defamation
- Dollar General adds two to board
- Tower throws down gauntlet in convention center land battle
- Rainforest Alliance speaks out on Gibson
- Bill Frist joins board of engineering giant
- HCA hires Waller Lansden senior partner
- Nashville's Superlawyers, Vol. II
- Feds raid Gibson offices
- Revenue cycle management company taps investors
- In Tommy Thompson's scenario, health reform passes this year
- Rival pediatric practices to square off in court
- Health care consulting firm acquired
- Dispensary of Hope partners with big pharma, state
- McWherter claims lead in Democratic primary race
- Earnings wrap: iPayment, Pet DRx, Debut Broadcasting
- State Senator 'testing the waters' against Bart Gordon
- Defunct ad agency pocketed $1.5M, Honda claims
- Nashville at law: Regions and hotel chain go to war
- Monetizing the mission
- From R&D to revenue
- The Food Biz: Chuy's charges out of the gate
- On Music Row: New acts opt for digital EPs
- 'We're small in terms of staff, but big in terms of network'
- Executive Appointments: 16 November 2009
- State roundup: TSEA presents layoff alternatives
- Dollar General settles into first-day range
- St. Crispin's Day 2009: The photographic evidence
- Executive shuffle at Tennessee Orthopaedic Alliance
- Permit Patrol: 13 November 2009
- Another quarter in the red for Symbion
- Dollar General comes back to market
- Balfour Beatty bases new division here
- Boult partner, Music Row lawyers form new firm
- Lawmaker's e-mail campaign warns of bogus threat to gunowners
- Locals bringing retail glitz to Cool Springs





And you get nearly-unrivaled health care coverage on our dime. F**k you, Zach Wamp.
This is the same Zach Wamp who said on the floor of Congress after the 2006 elections that the people we are fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan are a greater threat than our opponents in World War II.
Where is Wamp’s son? Volunteering in the US military?
Hardly.
He’s an official staff member on his dad’s campaign.
Poor Wamp. The more he opens his mouth, the more votes he’ll lose.
Thank God, this idiot has no chance of being our next Governor.
Wamp channels Yogi Berra on health care: “…if the uninsured don’t wanna buy health insurance, there’s nothing you can do to stop them…”
What this dimwit doesn’t understand is that there’s a cost to having so many people uninsured. They still get sick, they still show up at the emergency room, hospitals are still required to treat them.
And we (the insured) pay for that, Zach. We pay for it to the tune of 16% of GDP and growing!
So, instead of giving the finger to those without health insurance, why don’t you use what little gray matter you have left after your coke-addled youth and try to come up with a workable solution, eh?
The status quo is not an answer.
It’s a privilege,eh? How do you explain that we are one of the wealthiest nations in the world and yet we are one of the countries to NOT have some kind of insurance plan for the uninsured?
Most of the folks I have met in TN, DO NOT have the option for Health Insurance. It’s simply not offered by the employer or the plan is so bad they have no choice but to take it. Walmart is a good example of a company that cheats it’s workers by making them work 35 hours a week so they do not qualify for Full time benefits…
That’s about the dumbest thing I’ve ever heard. Of course they chose not to have it, because they can’t AFFORD to have it and still eat and have a place to live. Are you sure this guy isn’t still using?
Typical GOP rhetoric from a member of the priviledged class: I’ve got mine; fork you.
Can anyone show me in the Constitution where it says that you have a right to healthcare? If you can’t afford healthcare, then educate yourself and become competitive in the job market and earn a better paying job that has health care benefits. If you choose not to better yourself, then do not expect me to take care of you.
It’s not a privilege or a right. It is the output of someone else’s labor that you can purchase or not. Like gasoline, booze or corn chips, you buy it if you can afford to and you want it; you do without or beg if you can’t.
I want you proponents of destroying the last great country on earth to really understand, before you make one more idiotic comment about ‘rights’ that do not appear in the Constitution, that forcing doctors to work on your terms is slavery. Now you might accomplish it for a while, but when the next generation of doctors come along, who couldn’t make a living any other way than working for gov’t run health care, you’re not going to like having no free country you can run to no matter how much money you have. Not to mention, of course, the poor you claim to care so much about.
You commies are making the mistake of the millenium killing the last free country. STOP IT.
Womp is a dangerous dude. Is that really how he sounds or was NBC speeding up the audio?
Go nekkid????
And those caterpillars crawling above his eyes are distracting.
The congressman is so transparent in trying to find the right buttons to push to motivate a select group - the mortgage deduction (the realtor lobby), charitable deductions (non profit fundraisers), small businesspeople (the chamber of commerce) - yet I don’t really see how he addresses the needs of the majority of his district by using propaganda to remain in power.
I’m all for cutting the budget line item for health care, if the funds freed up in this manner are applied towards education - evidence of the need is no more apparent than witnessed here in some of the comments posted to this story.
Wamp has his health insurance, at our expense, so everyone else can eat cake. Typical GOP nearsightedness and the reason their “tent” is so small. I hope the people that elected this idiot read this article.
Most of these dolts commenting on Zack’s statements are bums who want to lay back and have the government take care of them. No country that has socialized there health care system likes the results. Those are substandard care, long waits, high infection rates in hospitals and many other problems too numerous to name.
I worked for a member in Congress, and their insurance is paid, plus when they leave Congress they are paid enough retirement to purchase their own insurance. With the mess the Republican party has left our economy in, it’s someone who is totally out of touch with the working class and people who pay taxes to pay for Wamp’s insurance, to make such a statement. It takes money to have insurance, job or no job, and today, the majority of people don’t have jobs or incomes. If one of his children, brothers, sisters, parents, or anyone else that he loves were in the position so many of our citizens in this country, would he still feel the same? I doubt it very seriously. Grow up Wamp, and get in touch with reality for a change. I’m glad I saw his comment, as I was thinking I might vote for him. NO MORE!
Jeff, when medical insurance is tied to employment, the unemployment rate is rising dramatically, and COBRA premiums are unaffordable for people drawing unemployment insurance compensation, what are people supposed to do when they’re sick?
Seriously, THINK about that. Don’t rely on worn-out rants against socialized medicine: what are people who work hard but lose their jobs through no fault of their own supposed to do for health care?
Get Real!!! Screw healthcare in the Constitution - as Americans we have the right to LIFE, LIBERTY, AND PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS! Right now I have a close friend dying from Cancer - she worked everyday. Where? In a doctor’s office - SURPRISE - insurance wasn’t offered and she still could not afford it! So where is she now? In the hospital, uninsured, dying of cancer AND with no hope of receiving chemo - they have denied her chemo because she is uninsured! It is time for many of you to do a reality check and think about what you saying and realize that Wormy Wamp is a Dumba**!
Yea, im with the majority of you wamp is crazy. But, the people that I really question are those who think people who don’t have “good jobs” are those who haven’t “worked” to have them. There are millions of educated hard working people (i have a grad degree) out of work. Not because of a lack of education or desire, but a lack of opportunity. I would love to get my money back for all the tuition expenses and fees I spent to go to college but I cant. The sad reality is if I get sick, because we are in the good ole USA, I will be cared for at a ridiculous cost and will not be able to pay for it. So some will pay more for their care to also pay for mine. We could just do that on the front end and get it over with. We are all created equal so we all have the same basic expectation to live a happy healty life. I mean lets be realistic what we’re saying is we have the technology, the facilities, the people, to save lives and improve their quality, but because the people who use them might have to do so at a reduced rate that is a problem. Didnt you jerks learn to share??
“So some will pay more for their care to also pay for mine.”
Aside from the ad hominems, this is the key point.
Look, we’re not going to have a society where sick people without insurance are going to be left for dead. I honestly believe that most, possibly all, conservatives agree with that basic point. Whether you call health care a “right” or not is immaterial. What does matter is how we, as a society, pay for health care for those who don’t have insurance as a work benefit. As the previous poster noted, we are collectively paying for it anyway. How can it be done in such a way as to minimize the costs stemming the fact that emergency rooms have become the first treatment option for the uninsured ill, without lowering the standard of care for the currently insured?
That’s an actual problem that can’t be dismissed by rhetoric against socialized medicine. Fine, let’s NOT have a single payer system. Let’s NOT ration care. Those efficiencies may not be acceptable. But what can be done to make the current mess, and it is a mess, more effective?
[...] Care Heartburn This morning’s video of Zach Wamp’s appearance on MSNBC regarding the President’s plans for universal health care was a little jarring — even [...]
Just keep thinking thank god I am healthy and a working individal BUT if the day ever comes that you are no longer healthy unable to work and uninsured–see how the Good Ole USA treats you. It could happen to you.
We keep wasting time on blaming those who don’t work, lazy, uneducated etc. Did you know that those are the ones who qualify for taxpayers Welfare–now does it make sense to give to those who are accustomed to taxpayers welfare and a Worker gets nothing in the end but a Bill? Makes no sense.
Just to prove my point Nadya Suleman she now has 14 children plus herself. The taxpapers whether they like or not will be paying for her, her children, and her decision. Those kids will receive the best education, healthcare, and housing that money can by–It’s called Taxpayer Welfare.
[...] Beale, a fellow TN resident, offers the reaction. Lots of comments over at Post Politics, [...]