feed icon

This One Not Like That One

Posted on October 20, 2008 at 9:26 am

Pollster.com compares the current presidential race to the 2006 U.S. Senate race between Bob Corker and Harold Ford:

The differences between early deciders and late deciders are opposite of what we would expect if there was a race effect among late deciders. Whites who decided within the last week and a half of the campaign were actually 8% more likely to vote for Ford than those who made up their minds earlier. The same pattern held for less educated whites, rural whites, and whites living in eastern Tennessee. The only two groups where Ford did not do better among late deciders was for low income whites and older whites. But even in this case, Ford performed about as well as he did with early deciders, not significantly worse.

What does this mean for the presidential race? It depends on the extent to which you think the case of Tennessee in 2006 can be applied to the 2008 presidential contest. On one hand, the demography of Tennessee would seem to make it a good place to look for race effects among late deciders. On the other hand, electing someone to the Senate in a midterm election is a bit different from electing a president. But if you believe the comparison, then the experience from Tennessee in 2006 would suggest that there is little reason to expect late deciders to break against Obama because of his race.

SEE ALSO:
Mark Mays breaks down why this is a shoddy comparison.
Bruce Barry finds this interesting as well.

Comments

2 Responses to “This One Not Like That One”

  1. October 20th, 2008 10:03 am

    Mays to the contrary, the reason Ford lost in 2006 is that he alienated the liberal base of the party in two ways. First, he consistently ran to the RIGHT of Bob Corker, and he refused to endorse the nominee of his party for his old seat. The combination of the two drove away enough white liberals that he lost.

  2. October 20th, 2008 1:55 pm

    LWC, that doesn’t jibe with what we actually know, but that’s okay, progressive netroots have proved themselves powerful in other ways.

Leave a Reply




The Collective

The Latest from NashvillePost.com

Archives