Tennessee’s Amazing Shrinking Tax Base
By Kleinheider Posted on April 30, 2008 at 10:19 amR. Neal comments on the news that Tennessee experienced the worst tax collection month in 47 years:
[T]his is the great thing about a sales tax. You can voluntarily give yourself a tax cut!
Comments
7 Responses to “Tennessee’s Amazing Shrinking Tax Base”
Partly Cloudy
Recent Comments
- Mary Church on Drop It Like It’s Hot: Strip Club Invitations On Capitol Hill Spark Controversy:
- Mickey on Tennessee U.S. Senate Candidate Willing To Sacrifice Senate Majority Leader Over Nuclear Power:
- Wisenhunt on TNGOP Calls Democrats Cranky Babies For Reacting To A Press Release Designed To Provoke A Reaction:
- Jon on TNGOP Calls Democrats Cranky Babies For Reacting To A Press Release Designed To Provoke A Reaction:
- Paul F. Dietz on Tennessee U.S. Senate Candidate Willing To Sacrifice Senate Majority Leader Over Nuclear Power:
- Kay Brooks on Retiring School Board Candidate Endorses:
Considering the number of people who qualified to run in that...
- Jon on Tennessee U.S. Senate Candidate Willing To Sacrifice Senate Majority Leader Over Nuclear Power:
- Kay Brooks on The Last Day Of The Legislative Session Is Tuesday:
- Jack Okie on Tennessee U.S. Senate Candidate Willing To Sacrifice Senate Majority Leader Over Nuclear Power:
- Mickey on Conservative Democrat Fights Doesn’t Want To Fight Fair:
The Collective
LeftWingCracker » Sharon, you leave me no choice, but to break out OTIS.
Posted 8 minutes ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Bill Hobbs, The Gift that Keeps on Giving
Posted 26 minutes ago
Enclave » Sure. Pay me to blog so that I can cover your print as you see fit.
Posted 89 minutes ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » Reject and Denounce! Part 342
Posted 101 minutes ago
Bill Hobbs » Tennessee Democrat Party: Out of Touch
Posted 2 hours ago
Southern Beale » Big Media Smackdown!
Posted 2 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » A Common Phrase ...
Posted 3 hours ago
No Silence Here » Shameless plugs
Posted 4 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » The State of Dean's Speech is....Crapalicious
Posted 4 hours ago
LeftWingCracker » Watch Obama PUNK Bush and McCain
Posted 4 hours ago
No Silence Here » Bloggers, citizen journalism and James Carville's visit
Posted 5 hours ago
Music City Bloggers » More internets fun
Posted 5 hours ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » You'll Take Our Nuclear Waste and Like It
Posted 5 hours ago
Music City Bloggers » Tennessean Survives Cyclone Nargis
Posted 5 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » UPDATED: Live-blogging Jewelry TV layoffs
Posted 5 hours ago
Nashville is Talking » Bible Theme Park tactics exposed
Posted 6 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » James Carville on Peyton Manning and John McCain
Posted 6 hours ago
Newscoma » The Office/Heroes Video
Posted 6 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » The legal technicality to end all legal technicalities
Posted 6 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » It’s a small world
Posted 6 hours ago
Music City Bloggers » Good Luck
Posted 6 hours ago
DeMarCaTionVille » Cherokee High School senior dies
Posted 7 hours ago
No Silence Here » Oops!
Posted 7 hours ago
No Silence Here » TN cops caught by speed cameras
Posted 7 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Hope Is a Good Thing...And So Are Toe Nail Clippers
Posted 7 hours ago
No Silence Here » Opposition to revenue-light cameras grows in TN town
Posted 7 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » What?! No Jimmie Rodgers?
Posted 7 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » Karl Rove helps Tennessee Democratic Party makes its case
Posted 7 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » SunTrust adds commercial exec
Posted 7 hours ago
The Donkey's Mouth » TNDP Chairman Gray Sasser calls on TNGOP to cease “grotesque” campaign tactics
Posted 8 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » This one’s for Dr. Helen
Posted 8 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » "Ordinary People are Not His Big Interest"
Posted 8 hours ago
Music City Bloggers » Interesting experiment
Posted 8 hours ago
Newscoma » Rick Rolls
Posted 8 hours ago
Tennesseefree.com » McCain’s dangerous backward foreign policy - a return to the Cold War
Posted 8 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » "If the Shoe Fits, He's Gonna Have to Wear It."
Posted 8 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » George Bush does Dr. Evil
Posted 8 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Better Fred than Read
Posted 8 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » He’s Mike Williams, and David Oatney doesn’t approve of his message
Posted 8 hours ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » Adlai Stevenson
Posted 8 hours ago
Newscoma » Stumbling Through Menopause
Posted 8 hours ago
DeMarCaTionVille » Last-Ditch Efforts at Drought Relief
Posted 8 hours ago
DeMarCaTionVille » Old Smokey finds New Home
Posted 8 hours ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » Register for YDA Conference
Posted 8 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » Accentuate the Positive
Posted 8 hours ago
No Silence Here » Another blogger's take on Carville's visit
Posted 8 hours ago
No Silence Here » TN native survives Myanmar cyclone
Posted 9 hours ago
DeMarCaTionVille » Memphis Medical Society prefers term “Lil’ Oopsie”
Posted 9 hours ago
Newscoma » Rep. Mark Maddox and CDS
Posted 9 hours ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » Thump It Somewhere Else
Posted 9 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » Liberals Win One in the Push for Gay Marriage
Posted 9 hours ago
DeMarCaTionVille » Ya’ll Get the Buckets: Clem’ll Get the Military Surplus
Posted 9 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » Who's Sayin' What?
Posted 9 hours ago
No Silence Here » TN Sen. Bob Candid, a man for higher office
Posted 9 hours ago
Bill Hobbs » What Happened, Bunker Boy?
Posted 9 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » Now if only Ted McGinley would comment here at Knoxville Talks…
Posted 9 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » I Dare You Not to Laugh
Posted 9 hours ago
No Silence Here » Quote of the day
Posted 10 hours ago
The Cutting Edge » Phil Bredesen: What happened, Bunker Boy?
Posted 10 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » How Do You Solve A Problem Like McCania?
Posted 10 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Attention, My Fellow Feminists
Posted 10 hours ago
No Silence Here » The conundrum of comments
Posted 10 hours ago
Music City Bloggers » Is The GOP Dying?
Posted 10 hours ago
Hispanic Nashville » Hondurans inspire Nashville teens, doctors, hospital, church
Posted 10 hours ago
Newscoma » How Will The GOP’s National Attention Impact Our State?
Posted 10 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Radical Leftists, in Context
Posted 10 hours ago
KnoxvilleTalks.com » The “generally affable” Mike Padgett
Posted 10 hours ago
Southern Beale » Does This Mean It’s Open Season On Cindy McCain?
Posted 10 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Reeling in That Marlin
Posted 10 hours ago
Hear ItFrom.Us » Another Character–Half
Posted 10 hours ago
Tennesseefree.com » Phil Bredesen’s Legacy
Posted 10 hours ago
No Silence Here » An IdleAire Ouch!
Posted 10 hours ago
Nashville for the 21st Century » Obama Calls for Talks with Hamas
Posted 11 hours ago
The Cutting Edge » Tennessee GOP slaps visiting Mrs. Baracky (PROUD for the First Time!) Obama
Posted 11 hours ago
Sense of Events » Eco hypocrisy, chapter 2
Posted 11 hours ago
Recent Posts
- A Question Of Effectiveness
- The Populist Privilege
- Well, He Did Say He Was An Appalachian Democrat
- The Bus Lobby
- A Cracker In The Coalition
- Where All White Liberals At?
- Mike Huckabee Makes An Obama Assassination Joke
- The Ever Present Bradley Effect
- TNGOP Calls Democrats Cranky Babies For Reacting To A Press Release Designed To Provoke A Reaction
- A Big Number
- Retiring School Board Candidate Endorses
- The Deportation Of Criminal Aliens
- Photos Of Democrats
- Harold Ford, Jr. To Meet The Press
- Compare And Contrast
The Latest from NashvillePost.com
- SunTrust adds commercial exec
- News Analysis: City listening for new sound from Sounds
- Ownership change at Franklin hedge fund manager
- Morning Links: 16 May 2008
- State's jobless rate follows national number
- Countdown to adjournment on Capitol Hill
- ISDN-Net buys consulting firm amid strategic review
- Sounds make line-up changes
- Morning Links: 15 May 2008
- Apartments slated for Midtown
- Real estate notes: Auto shop owner buys site across from LP Field
- Taking stock: O'Charley's CEO glimpses better days
- Morning Links: 14 May 2008
- MDHA awards convention center service contracts
- Ethics commission chair responds to former head of lobbyist group
- Mayor delivers 'State of Metro' speech
- Vanguard back in the black
- The word on Capitol Hill: FONCE
- Nashville at law: 12 May 2008
- Morning Links: 13 May 2008
- Briefly: Medical device HQ moving to St. Louis
- Sales tax collections come in at record low
- Restaurant association sticks a fork in leader
- Taking stock: NY money manager slashes Healthways position
- Insurance consultants open local office
- Morning Links: 12 May 2008
- Michelle Obama coming to Nashville this week
- Doc sues Waller Lansden attorney for malpractice
- Sounds cry uncle on Capitol Hill
- Nashville now and then: The dean of D.C. scribes
- Permit Patrol: 9 May 2008
- News Analysis: Why Obama should scare the hell out of Republicans
- Morning Links: 9 May 2008
- Area home sales still limping along
- Financial software firm names new president
- McLean victims may owe millions, trustee claims
- Morning Links: 8 May 2008
- Earmarked legislation could box Nashville out of millions
- CHS CEO leads local Entrepreneur of the Year finalists
- Puryear's judicial bid takes another hit



Up Next- TN State Property Tax
The ability to cut one’s own taxes by shopping less (or shopping more online) is a feature, not a bug. In fact, the decline in revenue indicates that market forces are working well - people are reacting to the economy’s troubles by spending less on stuff and on government. They are, literally, demonstrating with their reduced spending that they wish for government to be smaller and less costly too.
WHH,
That is the most tortured logic I’ve ever seen from you…and that says a lot.
People don’t stop shopping to send a message to the Government, they stop shopping because they can’t afford the items they wish to purchase.
They are, literally, demonstrating with their reduced spending that they wish for government to be smaller and less costly too.
Wow. Seriously? That’s why people are cutting back on spending? To demonstrate their wish for less government?
Ground control to Major Bill…
Hobbsie, you’re straying from the GOP party line. John McCain says that the economy is chugging along just fine, so I don’t know what “economy troubles” you could possibly be referring to.
They may not consciously be thinking about it, but when people cut spending they are making choices based on what they feel is most important to them. The result is that government gets less tax revenue. Despite an avalanche of headlines about how less retail spending means less tax money for the government, people still cut back on their spending.
Keeping government awash in cash simply isn’t their highest priority. As you put it, Bubba, people “stop shopping because they can’t afford the items they wish to purchase.”
One of the things they can afford less of these days is government.
The result is that government gets less tax revenue. Despite an avalanche of headlines about how less retail spending means less tax money for the government, people still cut back on their spending.
Bill, you just can’t grasp the concept that people just simply run out of money to buy things…can you? Is your wife or family loaded or something which provides you to be unable to know what its like to not have money to spend?