McMillan Blames Past Income Tax Support On Geography
By Kleinheider Posted on April 29, 2008 at 8:49 amExploratory Gubernatorial candidate Kim McMillan explains that her support for a state income tax in the past was based on the location of her district and that she would not support one today because we have the “type of tax revenue system that doesn’t need that particular type of environment’:
McMillan, who filed papers Monday creating an exploratory committee to seek the Democratic nomination for governor in 2010, said she supported the income tax because she was following the will of her constituents, who live on the border with Kentucky, which has no sales tax on food.
“When I had to choose between a plan that would allow us to remove the sales tax on food and make us competitive with Kentucky or increase the overall sales tax with no benefit to anybody, I think that was the choice that I took at that time in line with what the constituents of the 67th District told me that they thought was more appropriate,” McMillan said.
McMillan’s entrance into the Democratic race for governor will provide the first test of how Tennesseans react to a statewide candidate who openly pushed for a state income tax.
Since the great fight over a state income tax from 1999 to 2002, no candidate has run for statewide office who openly advocated for the income tax.
Tags: 2010 Governor's race, Kim McMillan, Lincoln Davis, State income tax
Comments
7 Responses to “McMillan Blames Past Income Tax Support On Geography”
Partly Cloudy
Recent Comments
- bcarrolla on Cao-ouch:
This is proof that there is occasionally a glimmer of hope in the Republicans.
- bcarrolla on Health Care Reform Bill Passes House:
I knew Cooper was too smart and compassionate to vote No on...
- Mark Rogers on Rep. Bill Dunn Openly Supporting Haslam:
9, Begin. Please. I am more than happy to be educated on how...
- Drew on The Reckoning Begins For Tennessee Right To Life:
- Ken on Health Care Reform Bill Passes House:
I predicted Cooper would jump in Nancy’s lap and do as she bid....
- thisoneisforthekids on Bipartisan Agreement On The Likelihood That Tennessee Will Have A Republican Governor:
- Mark Rogers on Health Care Reform Bill Passes House:
Mikey, Do you get the reference? Goldni, The last accusations...
- GoldnI on Health Care Reform Bill Passes House:
Oh, and apparently, the 218th vote was Bill Owens of NY-23....
- Number9 on Rep. Bill Dunn Openly Supporting Haslam:
Where in the Constitution does it say that someone has the...
- Blue Raider on The Reckoning Begins For Tennessee Right To Life:
The Collective
Camp4u » Josh Evans nails it
Posted 21 minutes ago
The Daily Docket » Pirates 2: Stagnetti's Revenge Trailer
Posted 31 minutes ago
Sharoncobb.com » Health Care-Reform Passes In Congress 220-215--Details Here
Posted 46 minutes ago
Sharoncobb.com » On '60 Minutes' Tonight (Nov 8)
Posted 46 minutes ago
Sharoncobb.com » On 'This Week With George Stephanopoulos' This Morning (Nov 8)
Posted 46 minutes ago
Sharoncobb.com » CONGRESS PASSES HEALTH BILL
Posted 86 minutes ago
The Daily Docket » Memphis Police Helicopter with Infrared
Posted 97 minutes ago
Cosmopolitan Conservative » Why I Oppose HR 3962
Posted 100 minutes ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Blackburn and Bachman Team Up Against Health Care Bill
Posted 118 minutes ago
SayUncle » Coolest thing about Droid
Posted 3 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Consider Me Pro-Choice On This One
Posted 4 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » He Thought You Said, “Would You Like To Smoke My Joint?”
Posted 5 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » BWAHAHAHAHAHA! Harrumph.... BWAHAHAHAHA~!
Posted 5 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Miranda Writes
Posted 6 hours ago
SayUncle » droid
Posted 6 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Pooper Scooper
Posted 6 hours ago
KnoxViews - » What we have here is a failure to communicate
Posted 6 hours ago
Blue Collar Republican » Distracted Again
Posted 7 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Beautiful Early November
Posted 8 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Our Commander-in-Chief shows his compassion for Fort Hood Victims
Posted 8 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » US Congress: 7 $100 millionaires, 237 millionaires
Posted 9 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Coloreds Welcomed!
Posted 10 hours ago
SayUncle » Zombieland: A brief review
Posted 10 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Jim Cooper: Mr. Compromise!
Posted 11 hours ago
Blue Collar Republican » So Very True
Posted 11 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Health Care Reform Act House Bill: UPDATE
Posted 11 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » President Bush visits Fort Hood. That Obama fellow trots off to Camp David.
Posted 12 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Diversity Is Never Your Strength
Posted 12 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Bell’s Bend Park is in Need of Help
Posted 12 hours ago
Blue Collar Republican » They Keep Failing And We Keep Allowing Them To Do It
Posted 12 hours ago
KnoxViews - » Madeline's qualifications for Mayor
Posted 13 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » House Vote Today! Bart Gordon will vote AGAINST ObamaCare
Posted 13 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Freedom, We Hardly Knew Ye
Posted 14 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » C'mon, now, we're gonna crucify Him for this??
Posted 14 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Hope You Were Hungry
Posted 14 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » The Warrior Song
Posted 15 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » The Tea Party in Florida makes it Official
Posted 15 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » An Updatey Update
Posted 15 hours ago
Tiny Cat Pants » Did I Tell You About the Hiestand House?
Posted 15 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » East Meets West Meets Middle
Posted 15 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Fort Hood: Islamic Terrorism
Posted 16 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Straw Poll for Democratic Gubernatorial Candidates in Hamilton County
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Let's Be Blount About Education
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Do We Need County Primaries?
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Chattanooga Tea Party to host Speaker Ramsey
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » How to win favor with the party during a primary
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Senator Roy Herron at SETPAC
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Special Election Primary Today in Germantown
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » How Not to Recruit Candidates for Critical Elections
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Rejected House 62 Special Election Headlines
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » An Extra-special Election: State Party Showdown
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Open Thread on the 2009 Nobel Peace Prize
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » Coffee with the Candidate: Mike McWherter
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » NCSL Gives Tennessee Legislature Web Site Top Honors
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » The Annexation Gambit
Posted 17 hours ago
TennesseeTicket » What Do You Call Hundreds of Campaign Signs in the Dumpster?
Posted 17 hours ago
Serr8d's Cutting Edge » Jason "Rot" Rodriguez kills because he is a Loser.
Posted 17 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » Two members of an inner circle of arrogant power: Lobbyists
Posted 18 hours ago
KnoxViews - » If displays like today are what they think is a smart political strategy, all we can say is: go for it
Posted 19 hours ago
Sharoncobb.com » Latest Beatles/Paul McCartney News
Posted 24 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » NJ Governor Elect Promises to veto any tax hikes
Posted 26 hours ago
SayUncle » zombieland
Posted 27 hours ago
Nashville Is Talking » 100 Monkeys with Twilight New Moon’s Jackson Rathbone in Studio B
Posted 31 hours ago
TaxingTennessee » CA Lawmakers: Pay hike good, pay cut BAD
Posted 32 hours ago
NO CHASER » Matthews to Cantor: Zip It!
Posted 33 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » Reagan Day
Posted 33 hours ago
The World According to Oatney » Reagan Day
Posted 33 hours ago
SayUncle » 5.7 “Caliber” a visual
Posted 33 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Jacobson planning health care investment fund
Posted 34 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » Last Chance to Voice Your Opinion Before Affordable Health Care Act Vote
Posted 34 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Permit Patrol: 6 November 2009
Posted 34 hours ago
Nashville Scene - Pith in the Wind » 'House' Quake: Nashville Designer's Movie Poster Goes National
Posted 34 hours ago
Six Meat Buffet » Bigoted, culturally insensitive post of the day
Posted 34 hours ago
SayUncle » That’s a big gun
Posted 35 hours ago
NashvillePost.com » Criminal charges lodged against financial adviser
Posted 35 hours ago
Recent Posts
- What Do You Want? A Medal?
- Cao-ouch
- Health Care Reform Bill Passes House
- The Reckoning Begins For Tennessee Right To Life
- Alexander To Right-Wing Neocon Muslim Haters: Chill The Fudge Out
- Something To Think About
- Should The Ft. Hood Shooter Be Charged With Treason?
- I’m Sure He’ll Get Right On That
- He’s Got Ties Older Than Them
- Everybody Hates Coop
- Lawmakers Worried About Jobs
- Bipartisan Agreement On The Likelihood That Tennessee Will Have A Republican Governor
- What Would Health Care Reform Look Like If Bredesen Got The HHS Job?
- Democrats Say They Have The Votes To Pass The Health Care Reform Bill
- Why The Health Care Vote Is Happening Today
The Latest from NashvillePost.com
- Jacobson planning health care investment fund
- Permit Patrol: 6 November 2009
- Criminal charges lodged against financial adviser
- LifePoint beats Q3 estimate
- Fresenius buys Nashville EHR business
- Newspaper publisher lures new equity funding
- Ingram Barge gets new president
- BioMimetic Q3 loss narrows
- Minority-owned law firm opens local office
- MDHA files to dismiss Tower suit
- Feds charge Hanover principals with Ponzi fraud
- Ad agency shuts doors
- Refining makes for rough quarter at Delek
- HCA volume growth best since '02
- C3 Consulting adds health care consultant
- Big clients drop Caremark
- The lucky six: TNInvestco winners chosen
- HCA more than doubles Q3 earnings
- Online retail community launches with $1.7M backing
- Law firm to reorganize
- Earnings wrap: CCA, American HomePatient
- Developer sues MDHA over MCC appraisals
- Easter Seals unloads property
- iPayment's Daily proposes creditor fund, monthly budget
- Kraft adds member
- Investor group buys Nashville Shores
- Harding Academy takes condo land off Coda's hands
- Police: Bank employee stole more than $100,000
- Waller attorney to chair O'More board
- Contractor acquired by Kansas company
- Brookdale to restart expansion program
- Earnings wrap: Gaylord, Brookdale, LP
- CCA picks up more Golden State business
- Newt: Well-being is more than a New Year's resolution
- Elon professor to be Belmont's first law dean
- Local attorney to chair Miller & Martin
- Bracken tapped for HCA chairman's chair
- Senate fundraiser brings back memories of old sex scandals
- Dollar General moves closer to IPO
- Nashville at law: Tech company sues Indian outsourcer





she would not support one today because she is runing for US Senate. can we say 2 face
McMillan wasn’t asked to vote on an income tax for her district, she was asked to vote on an income tax FOR THE WHOLE STATE, and she cast a vote in favor of an income tax FOR THE WHOLE STATE, which means one of two things.
Either she believed back then that an income tax was the best thing for the whole state, and is lying now about her motivation.
Or she still believes an income tax is the best thing for the state but can’t say so if she wants to win so she cooked up this cockamamie “my district made me do it” excuse for her vote.
Either way, she’s lying.
So Representatives aren’t supposed to represent their districts? That seems totally out of whack.
There is nothing illogical about multiple jurisdictional duties in elective capactities. You are a novice if you think a statewide candidate performs in the same capacity as a representative. McMillan would operate in accordance with the state’s interests in the same way she operated in accordance with her district.
It’s a good thing that McMillan’s income tax didn’t become law back in 2002, else Tennessee state government’s current fiscal crises would be a lot worse today than it already is.
That’s because, historically, states that rely on income taxes see bigger revenue declines during econommic slowdowns than do states that rely on sales taxes.
And, to make matters worse, states that rely on income taxes generally see stronger revenue growth during economic booms than do states that rely on sales taxes - and, as Gov. Bredesen showed last year, no revenue surplus is too large to spend it all.
Spending all of last year’s $1.5 billion surplus bloated state government and made it harder for revenues to keep up during this year’s economic slowdown - exacerbating the fiscal crisis.
The state now faces a revenue shortfall in the current fiscal year that may reach $500 million, but the state budget as signed into law by Gov. Bredesen was $723 million over the state constitution’s “Copeland Cap,” which is supposed to limit the annual budget growth to the rate of growth of personal income in the state. The theory behind the Copeland Cap is that if spending doesn’t grow faster than the average Tennessean’s income, tax increases won’t be needed to support rising spending.
It works, too, except when the legislature and governor agree to exploit a loophole and bust the cap.
In fact, if you trace the fiscal path that led to the push for an income tax back in 1999-2002, you’ll find that the extra $1 billion in revenue that would have come from the income tax McMillan voted for (and did come from the sales tax rate increase) was only necessary because the Democratic controlled legislature had approved busting the Copeland Cap by hundreds of millions of dollars in the previous decade. When the recession hit in 2000-2001, sluggish revenue growth simply couldn’t sustain all that overspending.
McMillan’s income tax would have been a fiscal disaster for the state of Tennessee.
- Bill Hobbs
[...] Braisted translates Kim McMillan’s explanation as to why she supported a state income tax for Tennessee in 2002, but doesn’t now: What I [...]
Hobbs, you refer to it as “McMillan’s income tax.” Wasn’t it also Don Sundquist’s income tax? And I forget which party he was the head of.
The funny thing about the legislature, d, is that governors don’t sponsor legislation - legislators do. Imagine that.
The income tax was sponsored in the state Senate by Bob Rochelle, Democrat, and in the state House by Tommy Head, Democrat. McMillan, Naifeh and a lot of other legislators - mostly Democrats - voted for it. Sundquist would never have thought he could get an income tax passed if the legislature had not been under the control of Democrats. After all, the Tennessee Democratic Party endorsed the income tax, and has never rescinded that endorsement.